The United States magazine for short-term-rental hosts RSSSearchSubscribe
STRGazette
Direct booking, Airbnb and Vrbo, and the rules, across the United States
Money & Markets

Washington Ballot Debate Highlights High-Earner Tax Contest and Host Revenue Impact

A high-profile debate over Initiative 645 in Bellevue highlights Washington state's upcoming vote on a 9.9 percent tax on wage income over $1 million.

By Carmen Delgado Money & Markets EditorOctober 12, 202611 min read

In October, civic leaders, political organizers, and business executives gathered at the Meydenbauer Center in Bellevue for the Eastside Leadership Conference, hosted by the Bellevue Chamber of Commerce. The central event of the meeting was an hourlong debate regarding Initiative 645, a high-stakes ballot measure that asks Washington state voters whether to keep or repeal a newly enacted state tax on high earners.

The debate placed primary architect and hedge fund manager Brian Heywood alongside Washington House Minority Leader Drew Stokesbary, R-Auburn, arguing in favor of repealing the tax. On the opposing side, state Senator Manka Dhingra, D-Redmond, and Children's Alliance Executive Director Soleil Boyd defended the measure, framed by the Legislature as a structural step toward rebalancing the state's tax system.

For short-term rental operators, property owners, and real estate investors across Washington state, the contest over Initiative 645 carries broader implications than a simple top-line tax rate change. The dispute highlights ongoing questions about state revenue reliance, corporate entity structuring, pass-through income, and the overall cost climate for running hospitality businesses in the Pacific Northwest.

What happened

The legislation at the heart of the Bellevue debate is Senate Bill 6346, passed by the Washington Legislature in March. The law establishes a 9.9 percent tax on individual and household wage income exceeding $1 million per year. Under the statutory schedule, the tax takes effect on January 1, 2028, with the initial tax payments collected during 2029. Washington state's chief economist projects that the tax will apply to approximately 25,000 filers and generate $3.5 billion in its first year.

Opponents of the tax, organized under the political committee Let's Go Washington and led by Heywood, qualified Initiative 645 for the November 3 ballot. Heywood previously petitioned the Washington Supreme Court on April 3 to secure the referendum process. Under the terms of the ballot measure, a yes vote repeals the 9.9 percent wage tax while preserving several consumer tax relief provisions included in the original 110-page bill. A no vote keeps the 9.9 percent tax intact.

During the Meydenbauer Center debate, Heywood and Stokesbary argued that introducing an income tax threatens the state's historical competitive advantage in attracting capital, business founders, and private investment. Stokesbary emphasized that high-net-worth residents play a central role in funding regional enterprise and development projects, warning that a new top-tier tax could prompt wealthy individuals to relocate out of state.

In response, Dhingra and Boyd argued that Washington's traditional tax model relies disproportionately on sales and property taxes, which imposes a higher effective tax burden on lower-income households. Dhingra noted that 41 other states levy an income tax of some form, stating that high-quality public services and infrastructure require sustained state funding mechanisms.

“Nice things cost money, and you cannot continue to provide all the things we love, the quality of life that we love, with the most regressive tax structure in the country,” Dhingra said.

A secondary debate held on KING 5 television featured former Congresswoman Jaime Herrera Beutler speaking in support of Initiative 645, while Washington State Labor Council President April Sims argued against the repeal.

9.9%Proposed Tax Rate
$1MWage Threshold
$3.5BYear One Revenue
25,000Estimated Filers

How the measure works

Understanding Senate Bill 6346 requires examining both its revenue-raising components and its spending mandates. Although political debate focuses heavily on the 9.9 percent wage income tax, the 110-page statute devotes most of its text to specific tax exemptions and public spending programs scheduled to start in 2029.

Under the statutory text, the tax calculation relies on adjusted gross income reported on federal income tax returns, applied specifically to wage earnings above the $1 million individual or household threshold. The threshold contains an automatic adjustment mechanism designed to rise alongside inflation in future tax years.

If the tax remains in place, the revenue generated is slated to cover the complete elimination of state sales taxes on specific consumer goods, including diapers, personal hygiene items like soap and toothpaste, and select over-the-counter medications. The law also repeals sales and use taxes for retail services, with an exception for advertising services, and expands state-level tax credit distributions for lower-income families.

Because Initiative 645 is structured to repeal only the 9.9 percent tax on wage income above $1 million while keeping the sales tax exemptions and expanded family credits intact, state budget analysts note that a yes vote would eliminate the revenue source intended to offset those consumer tax cuts starting in 2029.

Short-term rentals and federal adjusted gross income

A host in Washington, or someone thinking of buying there, first needs to know how rental income fits the federal definitions of adjusted gross income and wages.

Under Federal Internal Revenue Service guidelines, revenue earned from rental real estate is generally classified as passive rental income and reported on Schedule E of Form 1040. Passive rental earnings reported on Schedule E flow into federal adjusted gross income, but they are typically distinguished from earned wages, salaries, or tips reported on Form W-2 or net self-employment earnings reported on Schedule C.

Senate Bill 6346 targets wage income above $1 million. However, real estate investors who structure their short-term rental management businesses as active operating companies—such as paying themselves an executive salary through an S Corporation or C Corporation—may generate W-2 wage income directly tied to their rental operations. In those specific scenarios, wages drawn from an operating business contribute toward the $1 million threshold.

Furthermore, real estate operators who provide substantial guest services—such as daily cleaning, catered meals, guided tours, or on-site front desk operations—may be required by federal tax rules to report their rental activities on Schedule C as active business operations subject to self-employment tax. How state tax authorities ultimately interpret high-earning self-employment income relative to W-2 wages under Senate Bill 6346 remains an important area for accounting verification if the tax is upheld.

A tax policy shift in any state alters the baseline financial calculations for hosts managing high-revenue rental portfolios or evaluating capital allocation.

State tax structures and short-term rental investments

Tax policies play a significant role in shaping where short-term rental operators choose to deploy capital, buy real estate, and establish multi-property management brands. The debate in Washington state mirrors broader national discussions regarding state income tax structures and business location choices.

States across the country fall into distinct tax categories that influence short-term rental profitability and operating overhead:

  • No-income-tax states: States such as Washington, Florida, Texas, Nevada, Tennessee, Wyoming, South Dakota, and Alaska do not levy a general state tax on personal wage income. These markets frequently attract real estate investors seeking to minimize state-level tax drag on overall earnings.
  • Flat-rate income tax states: States like North Carolina, Indiana, Colorado, and Arizona apply a single uniform tax percentage across all income brackets, simplifying state tax planning for mid-sized and large rental operators.
  • Graduated income tax states: States including California, New York, Hawaii, and Massachusetts impose progressive income tax rates that increase at higher income thresholds, reaching double-digit percentages for top earners.

When state tax environments change, property investors evaluate the combined burden of state income taxes, local property taxes, corporate franchise taxes, and mandatory lodging taxes. A high-income host generating substantial income across multiple markets must evaluate how local state tax rules treat both resident and non-resident income earned from physical real estate located within state borders.

Schedule E versus Schedule C classification

A critical tax distinction for every short-term rental host in the United States is the operational classification between Schedule E passive activity and Schedule C trade or business activity. This distinction directly affects how earnings are taxed at both federal and state levels.

Most residential short-term rental owners report gross rental revenues, direct property expenses, depreciation, interest, and local taxes on Schedule E. Key features of Schedule E reporting include:

  • Exemption from federal self-employment taxes (Social Security and Medicare).
  • Standard treatment of real estate depreciation, including residential structural depreciation over 27.5 years.
  • Limitation of rental loss deductions under federal passive activity loss rules, subject to active participation exceptions and real estate professional status rules.

Conversely, if a host offers significant auxiliary services that turn a property operation into a service-oriented hospitality business, the IRS requires reporting on Schedule C. Features of Schedule C reporting include:

  • Application of 15.3 percent federal self-employment tax on net business profits.
  • Potential treatment of net earnings as earned business income, which can affect state-level definitions of active wage or self-employment earnings.
  • Greater flexibility in deducting certain operational business expenses and establishing tax-advantaged retirement accounts.

Because Senate Bill 6346 centers on wage income thresholds, hosts earning high net revenue must work with certified public accountants to review how entity structures, officer compensation, and service offerings shape their tax classifications under federal and state rules.

Sales tax and lodging tax mechanics

While Initiative 645 focuses on state income tax policy, short-term rental operators in Washington state must simultaneously maintain compliance with existing state and local lodging taxes. Washington levies a complex combination of sales taxes and special lodging assessments that apply directly to guest reservations.

Unlike income taxes, which are calculated on net annual earnings, lodging taxes are transactional consumption taxes collected directly from guests at the time of booking. Key components of Washington's short-term rental transaction tax framework include:

  • State Retail Sales Tax: Washington imposes a base 6.5 percent state sales tax on transient accommodations rented for periods under 30 consecutive days.
  • Local Sales Tax: Cities and counties add local sales tax surcharges, bringing the combined sales tax rate in many Washington jurisdictions to between 8.0 percent and 10.5 percent.
  • Special Hotel/Motel Tax: Municipalities and counties levy local hotel/motel taxes, typically ranging from 1.0 percent to 4.0 percent, designated for local tourism promotion and facility funding.
  • Convention and Trade Center Tax: Specific urban jurisdictions, such as King County and Seattle, apply additional regional tourism and convention facility surcharges on short-term stays.

Major booking platforms such as Airbnb and Vrbo automatically collect and remit state sales tax and standard local hotel taxes for listings located in Washington state under marketplace facilitator laws. However, hosts managing direct booking websites remain personally responsible for registering with the Washington Department of Revenue, calculating correct local tax rates based on location, collecting payments from guests, and filing periodic return filings.

The other view

The debate surrounding Initiative 645 reflects two fundamentally different perspectives on state economic policy, public finance, and business growth.

Proponents of the 9.9 percent income tax, including legislative leadership and social advocacy groups, point to Washington's public funding requirements for infrastructure, education, healthcare, and social safety programs. Supporters emphasize that relying strictly on sales taxes creates a regressive tax model where low- and middle-income families spend a larger portion of their annual income on taxable essentials compared to high earners. They argue that applying a tax to high wage earnings creates a balanced fiscal model that supports vital state investments while funding direct tax relief on everyday consumer goods like hygiene products and over-the-counter medicines.

Opponents of the tax, including business coalitions and initiative sponsors, argue that Washington's historical lack of a state personal income tax has been a vital engine for economic expansion, attracting software developers, entrepreneurs, corporate headquarters, and private capital. They express concern that establishing an income tax framework creates an administrative precedent that could lead lawmakers to lower the income eligibility threshold in future legislative sessions, eventually encompassing middle-class households and small business owners. They maintain that state government should manage public spending within existing revenue growth generated by existing business and sales taxes.

The battle over Initiative 645 is the latest chapter in a long history of legal and political contests over income taxation in Washington state. Over the past century, Washington voters have considered personal or corporate income tax measures on 11 separate occasions.

In 1932, Washington voters approved a statewide income tax ballot initiative by a substantial margin. However, in 1933, the Washington Supreme Court struck down the statute in a 5-4 ruling, determining that personal income constitutes property under the state constitution, which requires uniform taxation across all property classes.

Subsequent income tax ballot measures submitted to voters over the decades failed to pass. The most recent attempt prior to the current debate occurred in 2010, when voters rejected a proposed income tax on individual earnings above $200,000 and joint earnings above $400,000.

During the Bellevue debate, initiative sponsors pointed to this voter history to argue that state residents consistently oppose income taxes. Conversely, tax defenders emphasized that the current measure differs from past proposals by setting a higher $1 million wage threshold and pairing the top-tier tax directly with consumer sales tax repeals and targeted family credits.

At the national level, state tax policies continue to diverge. Washington is arguing over a tax aimed at high earners, while Florida, Texas and North Carolina keep selling low or flat taxes to draw new residents and business money. A host with homes in more than one state has to keep an eye on moves like this when planning the portfolio years ahead.

What to do with this

Whether you operate a single short-term rental property in Washington state or manage a regional portfolio of direct-booking accommodations, staying proactive about tax policy changes protects your operating margins and ensures legal compliance.

Here are practical steps hosts should take in light of ongoing tax policy developments:

  • Review your business entity classification with a qualified certified public accountant to understand how gross rental income, distributions, and salaries flow onto your federal Form 1040.
  • Audit your current reservation channels to ensure that all direct-booking transactions properly account for state retail sales tax and local lodging taxes.
  • Verify that your property operations maintain accurate expense tracking and depreciation schedules to accurately report net taxable income on Schedule E or Schedule C.
  • Monitor official announcements from the Washington Department of Revenue and local municipal tax offices regarding potential changes to business licensing requirements or tax reporting rules.
  • Evaluate state-level legislative and ballot developments in every market where you own or manage rental properties to anticipate potential shifts in operating overhead.

The standards desk (June Ashby) went over this story: 3 specifics could not be matched to the source material and were removed or reworded before publication.

Sources

Read and analysed by the STR Gazette desk.

STR Gazette is general information for hosts in the United States. It is not legal, tax or financial advice; confirm rules and figures with your city, your state agency or a qualified professional.

What readers say

    Never miss a note

    Read the desk every week.

    One click unsubscribes you. Your address stays with us and goes to nobody else.