Des Moines Considers Stricter Rules for Private Towing and Lot Signage
City leaders in Des Moines are weighing new consumer protections for private lot towing, highlighting regulatory challenges for short-term rental hosts.
A guest arrives at an urban condo or townhome rental late on a Friday evening, parks in what appears to be an open visitor stall, leaves the vehicle keys on the entryway table, and turns in for the night. The next morning, the space is empty. The vehicle was hooked up, pulled from the lot, and taken to an off-site impound yard overnight. For short-term rental operators, few property management issues trigger immediate friction faster than an unexpected private tow. When a guest vehicle disappears from a designated or semi-designated space, the resulting fallout affects review scores, host availability, financial liability, and platform communication channels.
In Des Moines, Iowa, city officials are debating how far local government can go to regulate private towing practices on non-public property. The discussion centers on fee transparency, drop fees, mandatory signage on private lots, credit card acceptance, yard operating hours, and whether municipal rules can mandate body cameras for tow operators. As municipal leaders deliberate, the issue underscores a broader operational reality for short-term rental hosts nationwide: managing parking access requires clear rules, legible signage, precise guest instructions, and a firm grasp of how local property regulations govern private vehicle removal.
The debate in Des Moines offers an instructive case study in municipal oversight, private property rights, and consumer protection. While public municipal towing follows structured city contracts and established impound protocols, towing from private lots operates under a distinct legal framework. For hosts operating in multi-family buildings, commercial districts, or shared residential complexes, understanding how local towing rules develop is essential to maintaining smooth property operations and protecting guests from unexpected vehicle impoundments.
What happened
During a Monday, Nov. 2 meeting, members of the Des Moines City Council discussed whether to establish a local ordinance with enhanced consumer protection requirements for towing from private lots. According to coverage by the Des Moines Register, council members weighed several potential mandates, including clear signage on private lots, requirements that tow yards remain open 365 days a year, limits on credit card processing fees, and mandatory price disclosures. The discussions followed action by the Iowa Legislature, which passed a bill during its prior session adding protections for owners of towed vehicles. That state legislation established tighter deadlines for tow operators to send notices to vehicle owners and lien holders, while extending the timeframe for owners to reclaim vehicles before they are classified as abandoned and sold at public auction.
Under Iowa state law, a vehicle is classified as abandoned after 24 hours. A reporting series by the Des Moines Register's Reader's Watchdog column found that Iowa's abandoned vehicle legislation had historically been among the weakest for consumers in the nation, creating opportunities for contentious practices among tow operators in the Des Moines metropolitan area. At the Nov. 2 meeting, Des Moines City Manager Scott Sanders stated that while the city had refined its public towing operations, several council members still harbored concerns regarding private lot towing practices.
To address those concerns, city staff sought council feedback on a list of proposed policy items to submit to the Iowa Attorney General's Office. City Manager Sanders recommended obtaining an official legal opinion from the state attorney general to determine which local requirements would remain within state legal boundaries without infringing upon private property rights. Sanders advised caution against passing a municipal ordinance that might conflict with Iowa statute, stating during the meeting that securing third-party input from the state attorney general would protect the city from potential legal overreach.
Some council members argued against delaying local action. Council member Josh Mandelbaum urged the city to establish its own ordinance without waiting for a state opinion, pointing to other Iowa communities such as Sioux City and Davenport that had already enacted local consumer protections for private towing without drawing legal challenges. Mandelbaum noted that state law governing abandoned vehicles applies after 24 hours, meaning a municipal ordinance could provide targeted consumer protections for vehicles towed within that initial 24-hour window before state abandonment rules take effect.
The debate also touched on specific industry practices and existing contracts within the city. Mandelbaum highlighted Crow Tow, a family-run towing enterprise operating at 826 S.E. During the meeting, Mandelbaum questioned a proposal that would mandate body cameras for tow operators, noting that Crow Tow already utilized body cameras and suggesting that mandating them across the industry might inadvertently favor an existing contractor rather than advancing broad consumer protections.
“I think it's an attempt to get clarification. We're trying to make sure that we're being fair to our residents and the people.”
Mayor Connie Boesen and council member Joe Gatto supported the city manager's recommendation to seek guidance from the state attorney general. Mayor Boesen rejected assertions that requesting an opinion represented a delay tactic or favoritism toward any single operator, emphasizing that municipal leaders aimed to ensure fairness for both property owners and residents. Council member Rob Barron expressed frustration with the procedural delay, noting that council members had previously discussed developing an ordinance during a June 8 work session and suggesting that submitting questions to the attorney general prolonged a process where consensus had already begun to form.
The proposed consumer protections
The list of potential private towing protections evaluated by the Des Moines City Council includes nine specific operational requirements designed to improve transparency for vehicle owners. First, private property owners would be required to post clear signage designating that unauthorized parking could result in towing, while specifying the exact storage lot location where towed vehicles are held. Clear warning signage serves as the primary line of defense for drivers, ensuring that parking restrictions are visible prior to leaving a vehicle unattended.
Second, the proposals mandate fee transparency by requiring tow operators to maintain official price sheets inside every tow truck and present those sheets to vehicle owners upon request. Fee schedules would also need to be clearly posted at all tow yards. Third, the policy outline addresses storage billing mechanics, requiring tow companies to charge storage fees on a strict 24-hour basis rather than calculating charges on a pro-rata or partial-day breakdown that inflates total redemption costs.
Fourth, the proposed rules would require tow companies to accept credit card payments both at the impound yard and directly on tow trucks, including payments for drop fees. Credit card processing fees would be capped at industry norms, such as 3%, preventing operators from imposing excessive transaction surcharges on stranded drivers. Council member Mandelbaum noted during discussions that Davenport's municipal ordinance already permits credit card payments for private tows, offering a working regional precedent.
Fifth, the city discussed implementing mandatory limits on drop fees, which are charged when a vehicle owner arrives after a tow operator has hooked up a vehicle but before the truck has departed the lot. The proposal suggested setting drop fees at a reasonable rate, potentially capped at half of the full towing fee. Sixth, tow yards would be required to remain open to the public 365 days a year for at least eight hours per day, preventing vehicle owners from incurring multi-day storage fees simply because an impound yard closed over a weekend or holiday.
Seventh, impound facilities would need to display 24-hour contact information prominently at the yard entrance and on their public websites so drivers can arrange vehicle recovery at any hour. Eighth, tow truck staff would be required to wear body cameras while carrying out private tows and preserve recorded customer interactions in the event a dispute arises. Ninth, tow companies would be required to share towing volume data across all private locations directly with municipal authorities, giving city staff clear visibility into overall private towing frequency and location trends.
Private property rights and municipal authority
At the center of the debate in Des Moines is the delicate legal boundary between local municipal authority and private property rights. Commercial lot owners, multi-family housing providers, and private land holders rely on towing services to clear unauthorized vehicles, preserve dedicated parking for paying tenants or customers, and keep emergency lanes unobstructed. When an unauthorized driver occupies a reserved stall, the property manager standardly calls a contracted towing provider to remove the vehicle.
However, when municipal governments step in to regulate how private lot towing occurs, legal questions often arise regarding municipal home rule and state statutory preemption. City Manager Scott Sanders emphasized during the Nov. 2 council meeting that city staff wanted to ensure any local ordinance remained strictly within legal limits. By submitting questions to the Iowa Attorney General's Office, city officials seek to clarify whether mandatory signage, fee caps, drop-fee limits, and equipment requirements can be enforced locally without conflicting with broader state laws governing property rights and commercial contracts.
In cities where local towing ordinances are active, municipal codes typically set precise parameters for how private lot towing must be conducted. For example, local rules often dictate the exact physical size of warning signs, the minimum height of sign lettering, the specific phrasing required, and the location of signs at lot entrances. When private property owners fail to comply with sign placement rules, any subsequent tow executed from that lot may be deemed unlawful under municipal code, exposing both the tow operator and the property owner to administrative penalties or reimbursement claims.
For short-term rental hosts operating within residential developments or commercial conversion zones, these legal distinctions carry practical implications. If a host manages a unit in a building where private towing is aggressively enforced without proper warning signage or clear contract terms, guests face elevated risks of sudden vehicle removal. Conversely, in cities with established local towing protections, strict signage and fee disclosures provide guests with transparent warning and clear legal remedies if a vehicle is removed improperly.
How towing disputes impact short-term rentals
For short-term rental hosts, parking management represents one of the most sensitive operational touchpoints in guest relations. Unlike long-term tenants who become familiar with property parking rules over time, short-term guests navigate new environments, unfamiliar neighborhood parking regulations, and specific lot rules during every stay. When parking instructions are unclear or when private lot enforcement is overly aggressive, the consequences fall directly on the host.
A vehicle tow during a short-term rental stay creates immediate distress for the guest, who may find themselves stranded without transportation in an unfamiliar city. The financial burden can be substantial, often involving an initial tow charge, daily storage fees, credit card transaction fees, or drop fees. In situations where an impound yard refuses credit cards or operates limited business hours, guests may be forced to arrange cash payments or wait through a weekend, incurring additional daily storage charges that quickly accumulate.
When a guest's vehicle is towed, the host is inevitably pulled into the resolution process. Guests frequently request emergency assistance, demand immediate financial reimbursement, or leave negative public reviews detailing their experience. Major booking platforms maintain strict guest experience guidelines regarding host-provided amenities. If a listing advertises on-premises or designated parking and a guest's vehicle is towed from a space the host represented as valid, platform support channels may issue partial or full reservation refunds to the guest, drawing those funds directly from the host's payout.
Furthermore, towing disputes can complicate relations between hosts and property managers, homeowners associations (HOAs), or neighborhood groups. In multi-unit buildings where private tow operators monitor guest lots under contract with an HOA board, unregistered guest vehicles may be targeted for rapid removal. If a host fails to register a guest's vehicle license plate with building security or fails to provide an official parking permit hangtag, the vehicle becomes vulnerable to private enforcement action within hours of arrival.
The other view
While consumer advocates and municipal leaders focus on restricting aggressive towing practices, private property owners, lot managers, and tow operators view private towing as a vital operational tool. Commercial real estate operators and residential landlords invest significant capital in maintaining private parking facilities for designated tenants, employees, and paying customers. When unauthorized drivers use private lots as free public parking, legitimate tenants are deprived of space, business access is hindered, and fire lanes or accessibility stalls may become blocked.
From the perspective of towing operators, private towing is a labor-intensive, round-the-clock service requiring specialized equipment, licensed drivers, secure storage facilities, and substantial insurance coverage. Industry representatives note that tow drivers frequently encounter verbal hostility or unsafe conditions when securing vehicles on private property. Operational requirements such as mandatory body cameras, extended weekend facility hours, and capped credit card processing fees add administrative overhead and capital expense to small, family-run towing enterprises.
Managing parking access requires clear rules, legible signage, precise guest instructions, and a firm grasp of how local property regulations govern private vehicle removal.
Similarly, municipal staff and city attorneys often urge restraint when drafting local towing ordinances. As Des Moines City Manager Scott Sanders highlighted, passing local regulations without verifying state statutory authority can expose a municipality to litigation from towing associations or property owners. Seeking formal guidance from the state attorney general ensures that local ordinances withstand legal scrutiny, protect consumer interests, and respect the legitimate rights of private property owners to manage their land.
State-by-state variations in private towing rules
Private lot towing regulations vary across the United States, reflecting different state statutory frameworks and local municipal home rule powers. In some states, state law comprehensively preempts local towing ordinances, establishing uniform statewide fee caps, required signage dimensions, and mandatory payment rules that apply in every city and county. In other states, state law establishes minimum baseline standards while explicitly permitting cities to enact stricter local consumer protections.
For example, several states mandate by statute that private tow operators must accept major credit cards and debit cards, prohibiting cash-only recovery policies at impound yards. Other jurisdictions require towing companies to take a minimum number of high-resolution photographs documenting the vehicle's position, license plate, and proximity to parking warning signs before hooking up the vehicle. These photo documentation mandates provide objective evidence in administrative hearings or court proceedings when vehicle owners contest the validity of a private tow.
Drop fee regulations also vary widely across state lines. In jurisdictions with strict drop fee rules, a tow operator must unhook a vehicle for a flat fee or a specified fraction of the full tow rate if the owner returns before the tow vehicle has left the property. In states without drop fee caps, operators are often legally permitted to charge full towing and administrative rates even if the vehicle has not been moved off the lot.
The legal classification of an abandoned vehicle also differs by state. While Iowa law defines an abandoned vehicle after a 24-hour period, other states enforce timelines ranging from 12 hours to several days, depending on whether the vehicle is parked on a public right-of-way, a state highway, or private commercial property. Understanding these state and local variations helps short-term rental hosts configure property access instructions that account for regional legal realities.
Managing parking and reducing towing risks
Short-term rental hosts can implement several practical property management procedures to minimize parking disputes and protect guest vehicles from private towing action. The most effective strategy begins with clear, pre-arrival communication detailing exactly where guests are permitted to park and where parking is strictly prohibited.
First, hosts should create detailed visual parking guides for every listing. Rather than relying solely on text descriptions such as park in the driveway or use visitor spaces, hosts can include annotated maps or photos showing exact driveway boundaries, assigned stall numbers, visitor parking zones, and street parking restriction signs. Providing clear visual markers eliminates ambiguity for guests arriving late at night or during inclement weather.
Second, in multi-family complexes, condo buildings, or communities governed by an HOA, hosts must rigorously adhere to registration protocols. If an HOA requires guest license plates to be registered with an online security portal or building management office, hosts should establish automated messaging templates requesting guest vehicle details (make, model, color, and license plate number) well ahead of check-in. Registering guest vehicles promptly prevents automated private towing sweeps from identifying guest cars as unauthorized.
Third, hosts should physically inspect the parking environment around their rental properties. Check that visitor stalls are clearly painted, that lot signage is visible and legible, and that notice boards display updated contact information for contracted towing providers. If private towing signs on the property appear outdated, damaged, or obscured by foliage, hosts should notify property management or the building board to request clear, compliant sign placement.
Fourth, hosts should establish clear house rules regarding parking compliance and maintain open communication channels during the stay. Instructing guests to display provided parking passes on their rearview mirror or dashboard ensures immediate identification by private parking enforcement staff. Keeping an spare parking permit hangtag inside the unit and replacing missing permits promptly prevents guest compliance failures.
What to do with this
To safeguard guest experiences and protect your short-term rental operations from private towing complications, take these concrete steps to audit and refine your property parking procedures.
- Review listing parking descriptions across all booking platforms to ensure instructions explicitly identify assigned stalls, visitor rules, and restricted zones.
- Provide guests with visual parking maps and clear photographs showing designated parking spaces, lot entrances, and warning signs.
- Implement an automated pre-arrival message requesting guest vehicle details (license plate, make, and model) whenever building management or HOAs require vehicle registration.
- Supply physical parking permits or hangtags inside the rental unit when required by multi-unit complexes, and include reminders in the house manual to display them prominently.
- Save the contact details for local non-emergency police lines, HOA management offices, and authorized lot towing vendors in your host emergency contacts file.
- Maintain records of all guest parking communications and registrations in case a towing dispute requires documentation for platform support or fee reimbursement.
This article provides general information regarding property management and municipal regulations; hosts should consult local ordinances, building associations, or legal counsel for specific advice.
The standards desk (June Ashby) went over this story: 34 details tested; 31 matched to the source material, with those sources listed below; 1 kept as general background; 1 cut before it ran.
Sources
- Bing News - reported November 13, 2026.
- Yahoo - Des Moines looks to establish stricter private towing guidelines.
- newjerseycriminallawattorney.com - Abandonment of a Motor Vehicle - NJ License Suspension Attorneys.
Read and analysed by the STR Gazette desk.
STR Gazette is general information for hosts in the United States. It is not legal, tax or financial advice; confirm rules and figures with your city, your state agency or a qualified professional.

What readers say